Ben of Into the Cryptoverse walked through roughly two dozen on-chain, technical, macro, and social indicators in a roughly 70-minute video, scoring each as either a bull point or a bear point in a deliberate attempt to set personal bias aside. The tally landed close to even, with the host counting more bearish points at one point but ultimately conceding that every cycle has indicators that both sides can legitimately claim.
Why it matters
The exercise matters because it reads the current setup without forcing a directional call. Bears draw the heaviest ammunition from indicators that have not yet reset: Bitcoin's MVRV Z-score bottomed at 0.18 in July and never crossed below zero, while every prior cycle low did, the realized price sits near $53,000 against a $78,000 spot, the balance price near $37,000-$38,000 has not been tested, the Puell Multiple has not dipped below 0.4, and the market-cap-to-thermal-cap ratio remains above 10. Bears also point to three prior midterm years where the S&P dropped 10-20% in Q4, the 50-week moving average at roughly $80,350 has not been decisively reclaimed on three weekly closes, and no volume spike has marked the low when every prior cycle bottom came on one. The QQQ analogy gets heavy airtime: launched at 48 in March 1999, it ran to 120, bottomed at 60, retested at 52, and ultimately bottomed at 33.
Bulls draw from RSI resets (weekly RSI at 26 matched the 2022 low), the recent golden cross, long-term-holder accumulation plateauing at the same level it plateaued in 2018 and 2022, the 2019 time-based comparison (about nine months from peak to low, similar to where this cycle sits), the "beautiful chart" cycle cross that triggered in June, and the cow-corridor indicator hitting its lower band.
Market impact
The host's read is that the indicator stack leaves room for a Q4 retest toward the realized price around $53,000 without breaking the four-year cycle, but also leaves room for the July low to hold if Bitcoin reclaims the 50-week MA on three weekly closes and the bull-side indicators start confirming. The whale activity score at 0.25 versus 0.89 at prior cycle bottoms is a separate signal: either final capitulation still has to happen, or this cycle's bottoms are forming without the typical whale distribution event. The practical recommendation is DCA through the second half of the midterm year below the 0.3 risk threshold rather than waiting for a single bottom print.
Frequently asked questions
-
What is the bull vs bear scorecard actually counting?
Roughly two dozen on-chain, technical, macro, and social indicators, each scored as either a bull point or a bear point, with the host explicitly trying to set personal bias aside. The tally landed close to even.
-
Which indicators are the strongest bear case right now?
MVRV Z-score at 0.18 that never crossed below zero, the $78K spot versus $53K realized price gap, the Puell Multiple not dipping below 0.4, no volume spike at the July low, and Q4 midterm-year seasonality where the S&P dropped 10-20% in three prior cycles.
-
Which indicators are the strongest bull case right now?
Weekly RSI at 26 matching the 2022 low, monthly RSI at prior-cycle levels, the recent golden cross, long-term-holder accumulation plateauing at the same level it did in 2018 and 2022, and the 2019 time-based comparison showing about nine months peak to low.
-
Why is the QQQ analogy central to the bear case?
QQQ launched at 48 in March 1999, ran to 120, bottomed at 60, retested at 52, and ultimately bottomed at 33 over several years. Bitcoin's spot ETF launched at roughly $48,000, peaked near $120,000, and bottomed at $60,000, so the bear case reads that as a roadmap toward $52,000-$53,000 before another leg toward the…
-
What is the host's practical recommendation given the split indicators?
DCA through the second half of the midterm year whenever the summary risk metric is below 0.3, rather than waiting to time a single bottom print. The argument is that the indicators can never all confirm at once and historically waiting for a perfect setup costs investors the move.
Whale Alert
WuBlockchain
Crypto News
WatcherGuru
CryptoSlate
CoinDesk
CoinTelegraph