TheBlock
Metaplanet shares slid roughly 10% on Tuesday, extending a two-day selloff to about 17% after CEO Simon Gerovich's public note failed to answer the structural questions investors had raised about the Tokyo-listed bitcoin treasury company. The stock fell 9.9% to 244 yen ($1.56) Tuesday after dropping 7.5% Monday, the first session following Gerovich's Sunday note. The decline came as bitcoin (BTC) traded mostly flat, down 1% over the past day at $78,464, isolating the selloff to company-specific governance concerns rather than broad BTC weakness. The underlying issue is the Series 10 plan adopted in December 2022, which tied Metaplanet's executive option pool to 20% of fully diluted shares rather than a fixed count, allowing the pool to balloon from roughly 46 million to about 319 million as the company issued shares to fund bitcoin purchases.
Why it matters
The dilution mechanic is at the heart of the controversy. Each equity raise to buy bitcoin expanded the executive award pool proportionally, meaning existing shareholders were diluted twice: once by the new shares issued, and again by the larger option pool that grew alongside. Gerovich said the company removed the adjustment provision and froze the pool at 319.46 million shares on Aug. 18, with a five-year lock-up through Aug. 17, 2031. Critics on X argued the change stopped further expansion but left the expanded size intact, and pointed out that Gerovich himself exercised 92,000 Series 10 units and received more than 64 million shares just ten days after the pool was capped. His ties to MMXX Ventures, where company filings have said he indirectly held a majority of voting rights, added a conflict-of-interest layer that the CEO's note did not resolve.
Market impact
The two-day move wiped out roughly a sixth of Metaplanet's market value while bitcoin itself barely moved, isolating the slide as a referendum on governance rather than a BTC proxy trade. Investors calling for the company to cancel roughly 273 million additional shares and replace them with a fresh incentive program applied retroactively remain unsatisfied.
Frequently asked questions
-
Why is Metaplanet's stock dropping while bitcoin barely moves?
Bitcoin traded down just 1% over the same period at $78,464, isolating the selloff to company-specific concerns. Investors are focused on Series 10 governance issues and option-pool dilution rather than BTC price action.
-
What is Metaplanet's Series 10 controversy?
Series 10 is an executive option pool adopted in December 2022 set at 20% of fully diluted shares rather than a fixed number. As Metaplanet issued shares to buy bitcoin, the pool grew from about 46 million to 319 million, diluting existing shareholders twice.
-
What changes did CEO Simon Gerovich announce in his note?
Gerovich said the company removed the auto-adjustment provision and froze the pool at 319.46 million shares on Aug. 18, with a five-year lock-up through Aug. 17, 2031. Critics argue the change stopped further expansion but left the expanded size intact.
-
What did Gerovich say about MMXX Ventures?
Gerovich said he is a 'significant but non-majority shareholder' of MMXX's parent company and has no role in its investment decisions. Earlier Japanese filings had described him as holding indirect majority voting rights, which critics flagged as a conflict of interest.
-
What are investors asking Metaplanet to do next?
Many want the company to cancel roughly 273 million additional option rights and replace them with a new incentive program applied retroactively. Others have asked for full disclosure of MMXX's ownership and any economic benefits Gerovich or affiliates received when MMXX sold Metaplanet shares.
Glassnode
CoinDesk
Crypto News
Crypto Rank News
WuBlockchain
CoinTelegraph