TheBlock
The US Senate's procedural vote on the Clarity Act failed 49-50 on Tuesday, falling 11 short of the 60 needed to advance, after negotiations broke down over ethics provisions tied to President Donald Trump's crypto interests. Research firm Bernstein told clients on Wednesday it expects the SEC and CFTC to pivot toward "aggressive and swift" agency-level rulemaking to fill the legislative void. The failed bill would have prohibited stablecoin rewards on idle balances and tied them to active customer activity; its absence leaves that framework untouched.
Why it matters
The vote stalls the most ambitious US crypto market-structure legislation in years and shifts the rulemaking load entirely onto the SEC and CFTC. Bernstein analysts led by Gautam Chhugani expect the agencies to tackle native crypto token classification, DeFi and self-custody protections, equity tokenization rules, faster approvals of real-world-asset perpetual futures, and coordination on single-stock perpetuals. The bill's failure also means Coinbase and other platforms can keep paying yield on idle balances, while the underlying stablecoins remain governed by the GENIUS Act. StoneX analysts led by Mark Palmer called the bill dead for this Congress, noting only 14 working days remain in the Senate before campaign season.
Market impact
Polymarket odds on the Clarity Act becoming law in 2026 had already collapsed from 82% in February to 16% before the vote, and Senator Cynthia Lummis suggested the next realistic shot at the bill may not come until 2030. Bernstein flagged a separate, slower-moving risk: the OCC and FDIC have proposed rules that could presume a stablecoin issuer violates GENIUS's yield ban if it pays an affiliate that then rewards holders, an issue that could end up in court once GENIUS takes effect in January 2027. The net read for markets is that stablecoin rewards stay live in the near term, but the legal backstop is far from settled.
Frequently asked questions
-
What was the Senate vote count on the Clarity Act procedural motion?
The procedural vote failed 49-50 on Tuesday, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed to advance the bill.
-
Why did the Clarity Act fail to advance in the Senate?
Negotiations broke down over ethics provisions concerning President Donald Trump's crypto interests, leaving the bill short of the supermajority needed.
-
What rulemaking do Bernstein analysts expect the SEC and CFTC to pursue now?
Bernstein expects 'aggressive and swift' rulemaking on native crypto token classification, DeFi and self-custody protections, equity tokenization, and real-world-asset perpetual futures.
-
Can Coinbase still offer rewards on idle stablecoin balances?
Yes. The Clarity Act would have banned such rewards, but its failure leaves the framework unchanged, while stablecoins themselves remain governed by the GENIUS Act.
-
When might the Clarity Act realistically become law?
Senator Cynthia Lummis suggested the next realistic shot may not come until 2030, and Polymarket odds of passage in 2026 had already fallen to 16% before the vote.
WuBlockchain
CoinDesk
CryptoSlate
CoinTelegraph
WatcherGuru