The SEC opened a public comment period on April 27, 2026, on an 85-item NYSE Arca rule change that would impose an 85% asset-eligibility threshold for commodity-based trust share listings under amended Rule 8.201-E. At least 85% of a trust's net asset value would need to sit in assets that already satisfy NYSE Arca's existing criteria — a list that, on the filing's own examples, includes Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, and XRP because futures on each have traded on designated markets for at least six months. The remaining 15% can hold non-qualifying assets, provided the trust stays otherwise compliant.
The structural detail is in how derivatives are counted: aggregate gross notional value, not net exposure. A trust with 95% allocated across Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, and XRP clears the threshold; a trust holding Bitcoin alongside OTC call options on a Bitcoin ETF, where qualifying exposure lands at only 71%, fails. Sponsors would have to monitor the 85% level daily and notify NYSE Arca immediately on any breach, with non-fungible assets and collectibles explicitly excluded from the rule's commodity definition.
Why it matters
The proposal builds on the SEC's mid-2025 introduction of generic listing standards for crypto ETPs, which already compressed individual product review timelines from 240 days to roughly 75 days. The 85% rule extends that framework with a hard eligibility floor — every sponsor now operates to the same math, which compresses differentiation but raises the compliance cost of borderline structures. The comment window is likely to run 21 to 45 days from the April 27 notice, after which the SEC can approve, reject, or open further proceedings. The GraniteShares XRP ETF cycle has become the textbook case of how procedural friction persists even inside the streamlined path.
Market impact
The filing explicitly names Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, and XRP as qualifying, which formalises the four-asset universe spot ETF sponsors can build against without bespoke relief.
Frequently asked questions
-
What is the SEC's 85% rule for crypto ETFs?
It is a proposed NYSE Arca amendment to Rule 8.201-E requiring at least 85% of a trust's net asset value to sit in assets that already meet existing eligibility criteria, with derivatives counted by aggregate gross notional value.
-
Which crypto assets are explicitly named as qualifying under the proposal?
Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, and XRP — each because futures contracts on the asset have traded on designated markets for at least six months, the filing's stated threshold for inclusion.
-
How long is the SEC's public comment period on the rule?
The comment window is expected to run 21 to 45 days from the April 27, 2026 notice, after which the SEC can approve, reject, or open further proceedings on the filing.
-
How does this build on the SEC's earlier generic listing standards?
The proposal extends the SEC's mid-2025 generic listing framework for crypto ETPs, which already compressed individual product review timelines from 240 days to roughly 75 days, by adding a hard 85% asset-eligibility floor.
-
Could the rule slow down XRP ETF approvals?
It could narrow the queue for borderline products: a Bitcoin-plus-OTC-call-options structure with 71% qualifying exposure would fail under the proposed math, and sponsors must monitor the 85% level daily and notify NYSE Arca on any breach.
Crypto News