A Manhattan federal judge rejected the CFTC's second emergency bid to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing her case against Kalshi. A state judge will hear James' request for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET Monday. Kalshi says the proposed order could shut its exchange nationwide and force the liquidation of open positions; James' office disputes that interpretation.
Why it matters
The proposed order would bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business within or from New York or serving people in the state. It covers contracts on sports, culture, elections and other events, and would also restrict under-21 trading and college-campus advertising.
Kalshi argues that because it is based in New York, the wording would affect customers everywhere. James' office says the order would not prevent the exchange from offering lawful futures or swaps.
The dispute is part of a broader clash over whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling laws. Federal appeals courts have split, with the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits siding with states and the Third Circuit siding with Kalshi.
Market impact
The immediate risk for Kalshi customers is the potential liquidation of open positions if the court adopts the proposed language, though no such order has been issued. The CFTC argues that federally registered exchanges fall under its authority and has directed Kalshi to keep operating.
The outcome of Monday's hearing will determine whether a temporary order is imposed and how its terms apply to the exchange.
Frequently asked questions
-
When will the New York court hear the request against Kalshi?
Justice Melissa Crane is scheduled to hear the request for a temporary restraining order at 11:30 a.m. ET Monday.
-
Why does Kalshi say the proposed order could affect all customers?
Kalshi says it is based in New York and that the proposed restriction on operating an unlicensed gambling business within or from the state would shut the exchange nationwide.
-
Does New York agree that the order would shut Kalshi nationwide?
No. Attorney General Letitia James' office disputes that interpretation and says the order would not prevent Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps.
-
What would happen to Kalshi's open positions under its interpretation?
Kalshi says the proposed order would likely force the liquidation of all open positions. No such order has been issued.
-
How have federal appeals courts ruled on the wider dispute?
The Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits have sided with states, while the Third Circuit has sided with Kalshi on whether states can regulate its activity.
TheBlock