TheBlock
Lee Reiners, a lecturing fellow at Duke Law and former Federal Reserve Bank of New York examiner, argued in a blog post on Friday that World Liberty Financial's WLFI token is an unregistered security under the SEC's own recent token taxonomy, despite the project's claims that WLFI is a pure governance instrument. Citing the Howey Test, Reiners wrote that "WLFI is not a decentralized commodity. It is a Trump-branded governance token sold to finance a centrally controlled crypto business," and noted that roughly 25 billion of the 100 billion WLFI supply was sold across public presale rounds before the lending protocol was even built.
Why it matters
The argument lands at a moment when the SEC is rewriting the rulebook for token classification — and is now led by Chairman Paul Atkins, who was nominated by President Donald Trump. World Liberty's own Gold Paper disclaimed equity, dividend, and profit rights, but Reiners contends that issuer marketing, Trump-family branding, and promises to "develop a crypto system, achieve functionality, build network effects" all satisfy the reasonable-expectation-of-profits prong the SEC's new guidance emphasises. The token was also allegedly used as collateral in a $75 million stablecoin borrow from the Dolomite lending protocol — whose co-founder, Corey Caplan, is a World Liberty adviser — with some of the borrowed funds denominated in World Liberty's own USD1 stablecoin, an arrangement Reiners cited as evidence of self-dealing rather than decentralised governance.
Market impact
The structural exposure is significant: a Trump-affiliated entity, DT Marks DEFI LLC, is entitled to 75% of net proceeds from WLFI token sales and is thought to own roughly 38% of the protocol after a $500 million sale of a 49% stake to a UAE-linked entity tied to Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan earlier this year. Justin Sun's separate lawsuit — alleging World Liberty froze his tokens and stripped his governance rights — gives the SEC a public record of unilateral control that contradicts the decentralisation narrative.
Frequently asked questions
-
What did Lee Reiners actually argue about World Liberty's WLFI token?
Reiners, a Duke Law lecturing fellow and former NY Fed examiner, argued in a Friday blog post that WLFI satisfies the Howey Test's reasonable-expectation-of-profits prong — roughly 25B of the 100B supply was sold in public presale rounds before the lending protocol was built, and the marketing leaned on the Trump…
-
Why is the SEC's stance on World Liberty politically complicated?
The agency is now chaired by Paul Atkins, who was nominated by President Donald Trump. A Trump-affiliated entity, DT Marks DEFI LLC, is entitled to 75% of net WLFI sale proceeds and is thought to own ~38% of the protocol, putting the issuer's largest beneficiary in direct alignment with the regulator's appointing…
-
What evidence did Reiners cite to challenge the decentralisation claim?
He pointed to a $75M stablecoin borrow from the Dolomite lending protocol using 5B WLFI as collateral, with part of the loan in World Liberty's own USD1 stablecoin — and noted that Dolomite co-founder Corey Caplan is a World Liberty adviser. He also cited Justin Sun's lawsuit alleging World Liberty froze his tokens…
-
How is the Trump family financially tied to World Liberty Financial?
DT Marks DEFI LLC, a Trump-affiliated entity, is entitled to 75% of net proceeds from WLFI token sales and is thought to hold ~38% of the protocol after a $500M deal earlier this year that sold a 49% stake to a UAE-linked entity tied to Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed Al Nahyan.
-
What is the next thing to watch on WLFI regulation?
Whether the SEC under Chairman Atkins opens a formal probe into WLFI's token classification. Reiners wrote that the agency has the legal authority to investigate but questioned whether it has the independence to act on a venture in which the president and his family hold a direct financial stake.
CoinDesk
CryptoSlate
WuBlockchain