A federal appeals court ruled 2-1 that Maryland can regulate Kalshi under its sports-wagering laws, adding to a string of legal setbacks for U.S. prediction markets. Three of four appellate decisions have favored state oversight, even as the Commodity Futures Trading Commission presses regulated exchanges to offer contracts in all 50 states.
Why it matters
The Fourth Circuit agreed with lower courts that Maryland has authority to regulate the business. Judge Roger Gregory wrote that gambling regulation has traditionally been a state police power and that Congress had not clearly displaced Maryland's concurrent authority.
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as other sportsbooks serving state residents. Kalshi argued that the judges' separate opinions showed there was no unified legal argument against prediction markets.
Market impact
The decision adds to the pressure on prediction market operators navigating conflicting state and federal demands. The CFTC has given regulated exchanges 30 days to return to nationwide service, while court orders have backed state restrictions in a growing number of jurisdictions.
Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase are among the operators affected by the federal directive. The industry and CFTC Chairman Mike Selig argue that event contracts trade on regulated derivatives exchanges and that federal authority preempts state oversight.
Frequently asked questions
-
What was the Fourth Circuit's vote in the Maryland case?
The appeals court ruled 2-1 that Maryland can regulate Kalshi under its sports-wagering laws.
-
How have other appellate decisions addressed state oversight?
Three of four appellate decisions have favored state oversight of prediction markets.
-
What has the CFTC demanded of prediction market operators?
The CFTC has given regulated exchanges 30 days to return to offering contracts in all 50 states, even as court orders have backed state restrictions.
-
What consumer protections does Maryland say Kalshi must meet?
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as other sportsbooks serving state residents.
-
Why do the industry and CFTC chairman oppose state oversight?
They argue that event contracts trade on regulated derivatives exchanges and that federal authority preempts state oversight.
CoinDesk